Casper vs Tuft and Needle Mattress: Comparison and Review

This Casper vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review is written specifically to compare two of the best selling direct mattresses and give an unbiased review on the built and comfort of each bed. The review and side-by-side comparison will be divided into three sections: the cover, the construction, and the comfort and support.

Comparison and review: the cover

While the cover of both Casper and Tuft and Needle seem similar in terms of functionality and color standpoint. The white sheets are equally thin, which is incredibly important and necessary to facilitate proper airflow, and both has a nice soft feel when touched. However, if you have a Tuft and Needle mattress, you should really be careful when moving it around as the material rips easily.

Comparison and review: the construction

Casper, and Tuft and Needle may be both considered as direct mattresses, however when it comes to the construction, they clearly have taken incredibly different concepts and approaches. Let’s begin the Casper vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review with foam layer comparison.

Casper, being a hybrid foam mattress, is built from four foam layers and is 9.5-inches thick. The top layer is a 1.5-inch responsive polyurethane foam that serves for none other than cooling and comfort of the mattress. The second layer is a 1.5-inch memory foam with a density of 4.0-pound per cubic foot that serves as pressure relief and to improve contour. The third is a 1.5-inch poly foam, with a density of 2.5-pound per cubic foot, this layer serves as transitional support to the base foam and lastly, the fourth layer is a 5-inch support foam that serves as the mattress’ foundational base.

Tuft and Needle, on the other hand, is only built from two different foam layer. The top layer is a 3-inch thick custom polyurethane foam  with a density of 2.9-pound per cubic foot. This layer is the signature of Tuft and Needle that is specifically designed to be incredibly responsive yet also comfortable as it breathes well. The bottom layer is a 7-inch thick polyurethane foam with a density of 1.8-cubic per foot that serves as both foundational base and support.

Comparison and review: the comfort and support

When we talk about comfort and support, the first thing that springs to mind is the firmness of the bed. Casper and Tuft and Needle may take a differing layer concepts, however when it comes to firmness, both mattresses deliver very similar result on the firmness scale. Tuft and Needle is definitely 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the highest mark; whereas Casper leads the way by a mere 0.5 with 7 out of 10.

Casper with its unique four layers concept is able to provide an incredibly comfortable “hug” feeling when you lie on it – a stark contrast with floating feel that Tuft and Needle provides. This is due to the polyurethane foam and memory foam layers that have the ability to conform to our body. Not only that, the combination of these layers also result in more bounce and response as well as better cooling, making it the winner of our Casper vs Tuft and Needle Mattress Review.